Calibration of Carbon 14 Dating Results

Calibrations of radiocarbon age determinations are applied to convert the Conventional Radiocarbon Age (BP age corrected for isotopic fractionation using a δ13C value) to calendar years. The short-term difference between the two is caused by fluctuations in the heliomagnetic modulation of the galactic cosmic radiation and, recently, large-scale burning of fossil fuels and nuclear devices testing. Geomagnetic variations are the probable cause of longer-term differences.

Calibration via INTCAL databases

The parameters used for the corrections have been obtained through precise radiocarbon dating of hundreds of samples taken from known-age tree rings of oak, sequoia, and fir up to about 12,000 BP. Beyond that, back to about 45,000 BP, correlation is made using multiple lines of evidence. This information is compiled into internationally accepted databases which are updated on occasion. The present databases are INTCAL13 (northern hemisphere), SHCAL13 (southern hemisphere) and MARINE13 (marine environments).

High-Probability Density Range Method

It has become common practice in recent years for researchers to use a mathematical method which calibrates the Conventional Radiocarbon Age then statistically refines the “likelihood” of one calibration range over another within the 95.4 and 68.2 probabilities. These likelihoods are graphically represented by a shaded grey area on the plot (higher peaks being higher probability) and by percentage values reported next to each range. The method is called the high-probability density (HPD) range method.

Beta Analytic High-Probability Density (HPD) Calibration

 

This more liberal approach to interpreting radiocarbon ages applies only to one single radiocarbon age measured. If multiple analyses are performed, statistically similar but different ages could produce different likelihoods. Despite this, the approach is considered legitimate and is accepted in peer-reviewed journals. There has been an increasing number of requests from reviewers to provide calibration in this format with the associated likelihoods specified. Beta Analytic decided to convert the calibration format to the HPD method providing stacking and averaging options upon request.

Intercept Method

In comparison, the calibrations Beta Analytic has historically provided were done according to a philosophy known as the “intercept method” which simply takes the intercepts between the error limits of the radiocarbon dates and produces corresponding calendar equivalent age ranges determined by the shape of the curve from the calibration database. In this method, when multiple calibration ranges are reported, all the ranges are considered to be equally likely.

Beta Analytic Intercept Method Calibration

 

This method is the most conservative indication of calendar age. Beta Analytic provided this format from around 1995 to early 2017.

Calibration of Marine Samples

Calibration of marine carbonate samples require correction for both global and local geographic reservoir effects (as published in Radiocarbon, Volume 35, Number 1, 1993). Reservoir corrections for freshwater carbonates (typically termed “hard water effect”) are usually unknown and are generally not easily accounted for in calendar calibrations.

Caveats

For wood and charcoal the possibility of an “old wood effect” must be considered as well as the potential inclusion of some younger material in the total sample. For carbonates, reservoir correction is theoretical, and the local variations are real, highly variable and dependent on sample origin. The age ranges generated by the program must be considered as approximations. The errors quoted on the 14C age (+/- X BP) which are then used in the calibrations are strictly limited to determinate errors (the counting errors of the sample, modern 14C standard and background). Indeterminate errors such as sample homogeneity, growth ring position (potential for old wood effects), relocation of samples (redeposition), and local reservoir effects in aquatic samples are not always quantifiable and should be considered in the interpretation of any calendar calibrated Conventional Radiocarbon Age.